Tools are Never Neutral
I was recently invited to speak to the Maine College of Art and Design to their Introduction to BIodesign by an instructor I connected with at the 2026 Biodesign challenge. A fun fact, I introduced the professor to the book Ways of Being by James Bridle, and it became a core part of her curriculum, with a chapter a week assigned as homework (heavy for the students im sure, but Its such a necessary read!) Anyways, It was situated in their Tools Unit and I reflected on the role tools play in our lives, how we design them and why, and the legacy they leave for us (in line with our conversation about OpenAIs AGI). I already presented, almost a month ago, and I wanted to share that presentation with the script in the captions. It generated a lot of thoughts related and unrelated to my practice and beyond. This was part of a MICA tour hence why the presentation mentions the MICA biofab program. I reference student projects and the principles of Biodesign set forth by Ryan Hoover: Making with, Making from and Making for. I also would not be me if I did not add some sci-fi elements (*cough* *cough* Ursula Le Guin <33333333333). Anyways: Here it is!
I will update this with my lab note book notes when I was initially generating ideas. Mind you, the professor only asked for me to talk about lab tools haha...
First off, to give some context, my name is Mantis (she/her) and I am an interdisciplinary artist and researcher working at the intersection of craft and science. I currently work as the Biodesign Lab Technician at the Maryland Institute College of Art where I facilitate lab practices, and support students as they enter and grow in the Biodesign program. My work aims to create access points of connection to the more than human world by using anchors of the human experience such as grief. I have worked and collaborated with several places that support this kind of work, such as JHU, BUGSS, Genspace etc…
As I stated, I work at MICA and our lab places emerging biotechnologies, including genetic engineering, biomaterial development, and 3D bioprinting, into the hands of artists and designers. The curriculum, which is led by the endowed chair of Biodesign, Ryan Hoover, explores the ways that living systems make things and how we can work with these systems in new ways. Through collaborations across disciplines and species, we combine a range of traditional, digital, and biological approaches that foster new modes of inquiry and explore solutions to the tremendous challenges facing life in the Anthropocene. The program is now expanding to include a Masters of Biodesign come Fall 2027.
Rhetorically ask yourself, What is the first thought or word that comes to mind when I say tool? As I was pondering on this and my my initial assumptions and thoughts were: (words and objects on the slide!)
And when I went looking into definitions of a “tool” and came upon one by Merriam Webster stating “A tool is any physical implement, digital instrument, or abstract means used to perform a task, solve a problem, or reach a goal”. This definition I think more accurately reflects the reflexivity of the term as it has evolved through time.
As you emerge into the field of biodesign and designing for and with living systems etc, it is important to reflect on the foundational principles set forth by those invested in the ethics of democratizing science. The DIYbio code of ethics was created in 2011 and has been a guiding tool for community bio labs and independent biohackers.
You recognize a problem and you realize you yourself cannot perform the function needed to address/mitigate the problem. This problem can be holding something. You need to use your hands for other things, so humans design the basket as a response to the problem of containing something for a pro-longed period of time. I call this Recognition and Response, in which the tool is the solution to a recognized problem.
You are extending an intent through an object.
Petri dish was designed and created by Julius Richard Petri in 1887 and is ubiquitous with the lab. The design stemmed from a need to isolate cultures in a manner that allowed for air flow without contaminating the culture. The petri dish holds your cultures to be observed, fed and experimented with.
The micro-pipette is a device that is used in laboratories all around the world. Its sole purpose is to aspirate a liquid, transfer that liquid to another vessel and dispense it. It was created by a post doc named Heinrich Schnitger. In the 1960s, The accepted and utilized form of pipetting was called mouth pipetting in which your breath in a long glass vessel would be the suction to aspirate and dispense liquid. You can imagine, this is potentially hazardous, which was the case for Heinrich and he spent a few days working on a prototype of the micro-pipette we love and know today. It is thanks to this tool that we have explored more intimately and widely the molecular domains of life like DNA.
The story of the microscope is one of glass and observation. The traces of the first microscope is a bit difficult to place, but the first iterations of the compound microscope start in 1590 by Zaccharias and Hans Janssen. They placed various glass pieces in a tube and observed that what they were observing appeared larger. The microscope revolutionizes microbiology as now we can begin to observe the microscopic more than human world. It is because of the tinkering of many individuals after, such as the polishing of lenses to form curves on the edges that would increase the magnification, that we have the microscopic capabilities we have now. This invention also magnifies the curiosity of researchers and it opens up the possibilities of the world.
This is a bioreactor, but bioreactors have more humble roots… with the ceramic pot often considered the “first” bioreactor.
A Bioreactor is essentially a container that holds a media in which micro-organisms are growing and as a result of the breakdown of the sugars and carbs available in the media, are actively making something else, usually an acid (also known as fermentation). Bioreactors have become really sophisticated and now optimize the process to be reproducible, maintainable and trackable. They usually are equipped with a stirrer to keep the culture in motion, and some other modifications in the event you need to add oxygen, nitrogen tec or check the pH or add a compound to the media!
These tools and instruments are made to observe organisms. But as we work in biodesign and biotechnology, you start to realize something…
Lab tools are also…
Living systems themselves!
These are natural phenomena that occur in the world and in bacteria that have allowed for the acceleration of the field.
A plasmid is a circular piece of DNA found naturally in Bacteria and we use plasmids to carry the genes we’d like expressed in an organism!
Restriction enzymes are molecular scissors that snip DNA at specific sites, and that allows you to insert a gene at a specific segment of the sequence.
The DNA Taq polymerase was found in a bacterium in a hot spring and is incredibly thermostable. This taq polymerase regardless of the sequence can build the sequence you want to amplify. They are vital to PCR which is a method of amplifying a DNA sequence by using a taq polymerase and various heat cycles.
The idea of these enzymes and type of DNA being considered a tool might not be an intuitive correlation as
1. The scale of an enzyme and of a plasmid is not observable to the naked eye. You can't use restriction enzymes like you would a physical scissor- it is facilitated in a cell, which in itself is incredibly small (it is molecular!).
2. These elements allow for life to occur, and we adopt methods from bacteria to perform a slew of functions. But you are still working with life, it is not inanimate. You are working with, from and for life, and that changes the dynamics of your relationship with the “tools” you working with.
3. There is not one size fits all. As that is rarely the case in man made tools, biology is highly precise and complex, and due to that complexity, biology shifts and it changes due to many factors. You have to engage, and experiment continuously as biology will act independently from you. They have agency.
Bee Hives: Making For
Making for is recognizing a need in the world or an ecosystem that you can design an object/system to mitigate a potential “problem”.
I know this isn’t immediately bio tech forward, but we have been making for life for thousands of years. It is a relationship we already have but a responsibility we have neglected.
The images you see of the left hand side of the screen are older bee hives
These objects carry a personal and ceremonial connection to the act of beekeeping, often made by the hands of the beekeeper. The designs were responsive and intuitive, perhaps reciprocal. But in 1852, the modern hive got patented and beekeeping as a field adopted this model and subsequently, various tools and technologies were designed specifically to this design. It was optimal, efficient and cheaper. However, this has, not maliciously intended, erased the historical and architectural history of beehives. Which, in turn, has reframed our relationship to honey extraction and bee-keeping as a relational practice. When you are making for a being/community, did your tool change the access you have to the beings in order to optimize a process? Neither is right or wrong, but in our current climate, it is a reflection to keep.
Making with is symbiotic relationship between human and more-than-human worlds to create a new material, object or system.
Cell-Phonic was a Biodesign challenge project from MICA, and the students spent their spring semester developing an interactive bio-tech interface designed to explore communication between humans and microorganisms. Based on microbial fuel cell research, the students were fascinated with the way micro-organisms “communicate” to each other, which was through electrical signaling. A microbial fuel cell is essentially a biological battery.
The students redesigned a microbial fuel cell and housed the MFCs in an interface. The instrument translates shared audio and electrical signals into a medium for speculative cross-species dialogue.
The project challenges anthropocentric ideas of intelligence by positioning microbes as collaborators rather than passive systems. Its low-resolution, transparent design emphasizes translation and uncertainty, suggesting that even imperfect attempts at understanding non-human life can foster new forms of ecological connection and collaboration.
This project SHAPES a relationship to the micro-organisms through the re-design of a microbial fuel cell. What I appreciate about this project is the respect to human made invention that is a familiar communication tool so that communication becomes intuitive while also respecting the environment the organisms needed to survive. By adopting a system that was translatable, Agency is given to both the human and the cultures in how the object itself was designed and therefore facilitates the interaction and that intention.
(For context, the class I was presenting to did microbial paintings that same day!)
Microbial Prints: Making from!
Making from is defined as the adoption and integration of a body or function from an organism as a means to create a solution or solve a problem.
You guys are making microbial drawings that were edited most likely using a plasmid to insert a gene that will express a protein that produces the color palette! You are making from life. The bacteria is alive, and you will most likely observe a variance, might be surprised by the unpredictability.
I feel like microbial prints are a great activity for artists and designers to break into biotech/biodesign. It gets you familiar with the practical technique and the needed precision to express the protein, with the intuition to create something from “them”. It is not immediately gratifying, and life asks for your patience in order to do what life does best, which is to grow. The petri dish, in this way, becomes a container to hold and facilitate a relationship you are familiarizing yourself with. In the MICA lab, we also encourage the re-design of petri dishes, with some students using ceramic etc to be more intentional/present with the culture.
“Before the tool that extends energy outward, we made the tool that brings energy home.” the carrier bag theory
This quote is developing upon the idea that before we designed the weapon, we made the basket. Just like in Ways of Being, in which James Bridle, pushes back against the notion we killed off the neanderthals and instead pedestals a theory of species integration. We cared and loved each other into one being. Ursula Le Guin is reckoning with the same idea, but within the human made objects that tell us a different story of humanity. One of holding, and of caring before dominance and violence.
Biological tools are not solely tools made, but are creators in and of themselves. Here the tool itself makes and unmakes the world through motion and practice. A tool becomes a practical and theoretical ecology-a mediation between beings and the environment.
All this to imply that, Your design has a future. The urgency and immediacy of which you respond will generate great ideas and very proactive ones, but your ideas, in object, and action, have a legacy. We have seen this time and time again. Think of your designs future as you would a generation. Think about how your design and/or tool could/would be transformed, the possible evolutions and adaptations that may occur through use, its manufacturing, and cycle and the relationships it creates as a result of the functionality.
Don’t just redesign an object, reimagine a relationship.
One of my favorite quotes ever! <--- I did not say this during the presentation haha.
I do think this quote has directly informed my itch to expand the question "what is like to be you?" and creating technologies that respect the human while also respecting the more than human world.
Some books and resources that helped shape my thoughts and the presentation!
I still have a lot of thoughts but would appreciate hearing what you guys think first!
Comments