On Tattoos & Scars, Blogs & Sex
Wanted to write an essay for the film I'm hoping to create. I hope this is appropriate for this space! <3
Way back in August, I booked a tattoo appointment for the express purpose of marking my body with an animation field*. I'd wanted this for a while, and the project I'm cooking up for this residency ended up being an excuse to have a space to animate on my body: I had watched my friend & mentor, Declan McKenna, do something similar for their film bEACH, and I was eager to play with my own body as a surface.
*I should also mention that an animation "field" is just an area that an animation is drawn in. There used to be specially-made paper for animation: 12-field (12 inch wide paper), or 16-field (16 inch paper) that would serve either TV or theatrical animation. They're usually marked with "registration points", which make sure that each frame is aligned to the one before/after it, to avoid any unnecessary shakiness. My tattoo would be a 3-field spot on my knee with 4 cross hairs marking each corner of the animate-able area, and a circle to serve as an extra point of alignment.
Anyway - that appointment was scheduled for this past Saturday. After a serious of deeply unfortunate events, here I sit: tattoo-less. The tattoo artist had been having a rough week and just wasn't prepared to tattoo me. So I swallowed my irritation and rescheduled. I had a number of reasons to be pissed - I had made this appointment nearly two months ago and had been looking forward to it as a reward after a particularly exhausting month. But ultimately, would I want the work of a visibly frazzled tattoo artist to mark my body forever? And now the question remains - do I trust them to do this at all?
It got me thinking about this notion of staining. This project is about me staining my body in a number of ways. There's the permanent kind of stain, my tattoo. I'll need to figure out the kind of temporary pigment to stain my knee with when I actually begin animating - something that can wipe off easily between frames so I can animate in appropriately fast sessions. And I guess it's about the ways in which I was stained -- changed, transformed, colored by -- the relationships that I've been in. This is a film about separating, but I guess you can't separate cleanly. Something gets left behind.
Tattoos work by wounding the skin to insert pigments, so that when it heals the pigment remains trapped below the skin. Most surface wounds heal invisibly - evidence of whatever pierced you faint, if visible at all. When I think about the permanence of a tattoo, I feel like my reasoning to get one should feel deeper than the aesthetic thing I'd like to keep on my body. But I guess it turns into that when you run your fingers over the mark and remember when you got it.
For example: I got my first (and currently only tattoo) with my then-girlfriend in the room. Our relationship had been slowing in momentum for a while, and the hurdles that would eventually cause the end of our relationship were starting to emerge. I was just too scared to voice my pains with her because they made me sound like an absolute freak to myself, so they sat like a stone on my chest for months. When I told her I would get a tattoo on my ribs, she asked to be there. I said yes.
My ex waited in the room while a stranger handpoked me with a flower that I didn't know the name of. It was a flash design, and I had picked the tattoo artist because I had just seen her designs on my peers and saw how beautiful the curvaceous forms she used were on the skin. When I saw this tattoo artist next -- almost year and a half later -- she didn't recognize me. But she had marked me forever, and had given me a tattoo that I would run my fingers over as I mourned my two year relationship 7 months after she had given it to me.
I fantasize about a clean break often: ending a relationship by closing the book, and never reopening it. Our lives remain our own, as if the relationship had never happened in the first place.
For what it's worth, I've never messaged a lover after we decided when we ended, even if we agreed to "just" be friends. The most I've done is cyberstalk them through instagram and wonder what would happen if we had tried to make it work. And then I distract myself, because those feelings are dangerous. I try and scrub out the stain, and refuse to credit any of the changes I've made in my life to whoever it was I just broke up with. I try to ignore the ways they marked me, and try and deepen the ways they altered my life so that my life remains mine alone.
When my first serious girlfriend and I broke up, I threw myself into the indie internet. I decided I was going to hand-code a website, delete all social media off my phone, and get my news from RSS feeds and some trusted activist news orgs on the ground. I got really into my own email inbox. And yes, a huge part of this was to occupy myself so I didn't think about the breakup, and how even then I didn't really get to voice how I was feeling... but it ended up taking me down a rabbit hole that put me in this cohort. It also stopped me from refreshing her instagram page, praying for an update that would free me from the lingering "what if?"
I suppose I was avoiding my own passivity. The relationship had fallen apart because I never new how to voice the ways in which I was struggling. Early on, the first time we had had sex, I realized that she wasn't all that attracted to me. I couldn't accuse her of that, though, that being with me was a chore, because she was kind and paid for our dinners most of the time (we would playfully fight over who got to pay. She usually won). I loved her a lot, and tried to convince myself that I could be with someone who didn't desire me in the way I wanted to be desired. So when we broke up, I was certain of one thing: sex would be unfulfilling and painful for me. So I promised myself I wouldn't date until 2 years had passed - the same length of time our relationship lasted. It was a relationship that had steered me away from the idea of love all together.
I read so much, in that time. Mostly blog posts, essays, the like. A post I stumbled upon early was The Open Web As A Gift Economy by Tracy Durnell. (Mantis, you will be familiar with this as it was my reading for Tomato Town!) It's an essay about the internet, Robin Wall Kimmerer's The Serviceberry, and the wonders of the hyperlink.
Even if we read the same twenty articles, you and I will probably spot different connections and draw different conclusions… and this is part of the power of seeing how and what others link. Jennings identifies that “Links treat creativity as the work of remediating and remaking…” (A linkless internet, Colin Jennings). L.M. Sacasas describes the great gift of thinking with others online:
"I think of knowledge as something more personal, something that emerges within us as we take in the world from our own unique perspective but also as members of particular communities. In doing so, we construct relationships among the things we come to know (and not merely know about), these relationships are shaped by our history and our desires. And this knowledge, carried within, shapes our ongoing encounters with the world, building a cascading experience of “understanding in light of,” a form of poetic knowledge."
Relational creation means recognizing the value that others have brought to you, and wanting to acknowledge it publicly. That means crediting… that means linking. Just because something is posted online doesn’t mean it is “up for grabs.”* As an elder millennial, I developed my norms around linking in the age of blogs, not social media. I don’t say this to claim superiority, but to recognize the influence of the environment on our beliefs and norms… and the open web is an environment that rewards linking, whereas the closed web actively prevents it.
It's a blog post that fundamentally shifted my relationship with the internet. It marked me in its own way: introducing me to an author that transformed my life. That following summer I would go on a camping trip with my closest friends (now Animation Love Affair) in Acadia, Maine. Knowing I had been obsessed with this blog post, my friend Nadia lent me a copy of The Serviceberry to read in the car. I gave it back to her when we returned to Baltimore, and she transformed it into a gift for me with a note in the front cover.
In Maine, I tripped on a rock and got a cut that needed stitches and a 3 month-long healing process. Now, my left eyebrow has a slash that leads into my nose. When I take my shirt off and look at myself in the mirror - tattooed, scarred in new ways - I am a fundamentally different person than the person I was in my relationship. My life before reading this book, before Acadia, Maine, before reading The Web as a Gift Economy feels so fundamentally different from the life I live now. I have been stained, marked, changed by all these moments. Scars aren't inherently traumatic, and I guess breakups aren't either. They just changed the surface of my skin and the membrane of my soul, and now I am a new me.
I've never really had a film become something as this one is. I feel like it's gestating inside me, as I think about tattoos and my own flailing attempts at grasping for romance and intimacy. I think about the number one critique that's been levied against me by ex-girlfriends - I'm impenetrable (unlike the soft skin I portray myself to have), my walls are up. I don't want to let them in. I often do the same in my artwork (and as I write this blog post I cringe at my own directness) - hide the emotional truth behind structure and rules and medium. I don't really want to be known, because being known opens me up to be forgotten or betrayed. And while being known also opens me up to satisfaction, I think I'm comfortable in that unfulfillment. I hate the idea of receiving satisfaction and then it being taken away from me.
A space must be maintained or desire ends. Sappho reconstructs the space of desire in a poem that is like a small, perfect photograph of the erotic dilemma. (Eros the Bittersweet, Anne Carson, p 48)
January 20th, 2027 will mark two years since I broke up with my ex-girlfriend. I broke the promise I had made to myself when that relationship ended - that I wouldn't start dating again until the length of our relationship had passed. I wonder if this film is in some way related to that. After the first year of successfully focusing on my platonic relationships, I felt an itch. I wanted to feel desired. I wondered why nobody had held my gaze for too long, why I hadn't felt the want of another person before. I felt hungry, a feeling I thought I had successfully kept under wraps.
In May of this past year, I had hit an emotional low that surprised me. I was burnt out from my day job, was regularly vomiting at work from anxiety, and was desperate for a distraction. I wasn't eager to break my social media detox that had been successfully ongoing for 6 months, so I needed to find something else. There was a lesbian dating app that I had been downloading and deleting since being single that I redownloaded again after a particularly tear-filled night. I updated my photos to include my new bleached eyebrows, changed what I was looking for to "something casual" and tried to find someone to distract myself with.
For the first time since I had debuted on the dating scene, I received a message almost immediately after reactivating my account. A tall, muscular woman with a fascinating facial scar and a very sweet smile told me I was pretty. We sent two messages to each other before she gave me her number and told me she wanted to take me on a date. I texted her the next day, curious. We scheduled a date at a skating rink a week from then. I prepared to be disappointed.
That Wednesday, I mentioned to her offhand that I was going to a karaoke night with my friends. "Can I join you?" She responded, almost immediately, "I mean, I get it if it's weird. That just sounds so fun and I think it would feel better for you if I met you around your friends." I was surprised but felt something in me soften a little, so I said yes. I let my friends know that this person I was talking to might show at our sacred karaoke Wednesday. When she came, she laid it all out on the table -- told us she was recently back in the dating scene after not being into it, the story behind her star (an ex's dog had attacked her, ripping away her upper lip), and that she was very attracted to me. She asked me what I wanted. I tried to be honest, unsure what she wanted to hear from me. "I'm in a transitional place, so something casual," I said, finally, "But I'm willing to see where things go."
What would emerge from meeting this girl was a very strange 3-month situationship. I mentioned my woes about my ex to her and she seemed determined to erase whatever bad feelings I had about sex by showing me it was possible to enjoy it (she succeeded). She was visibly very into me, and I into her: both of us would catch the other staring a little longer than necessary, and when we came together I felt lighter than air. Suddenly, I felt normal, like I had finally unlocked a part of myself that I didn't even know existed. I found myself desiring, openly. I found myself figuring out what I wanted.
Not to say everything with her was good, or enjoyable even most of the time. Whatever I chose as a date usually failed to impress her, and her dates were mostly an opportunity for her to show off her skill rather than a place for me to enjoy myself. She drove recklessly and a little under the influence. And if I had found a break in her long-winded stories to insert an opinion or mention a fact about myself that wasn't about sex, it went unheard.
She once gave a tour of the many tattoos on her body. An eye of Horus behind her ear, abstract shapes on her arm. She told me that the one on her wrist was given to her by a tattoo artist she admired, and he had killed himself not too long ago. She told me it felt strange to think that the marks he had made on her would live longer than he did. Her eyes glistened a little when she told me that, and then she blinked whatever mistyness was there away to cajole me into undressing.
I found myself wanting, imagining. Thinking about things to say that would impress her, make her want to know more about me than just my body. I found myself changing through knowing her -- knowing myself both more and less, getting more confident and at the same time so much more unsure about myself. Even now, I think about our trysts and I understand that what she did for me was open a door into myself. I worry that the door closed behind her once she disappeared from my life (she ghosted me without much pomp or circumstance, and I never resisted her slow draw away because, if I'm being honest, I was doing the same myself). Is the Mars that revealed itself in those nights gone forever? Will I ever feel that desire, reciprocated in the strange way that it was, since?
Still, I'm grateful. For all of it - the exes and tattoos and scars and situationships. All of the stains and marks and scratches and bumps tell a story on my skin that I can retell to myself and my friends. There is some new wisdom to be found there with each encore. I don't regret much of it. I don't try and scrub the reminders of touch away. I'm comfortable with having a past now, I think.
When I think about this film, about parting, I'm thinking what it all meant. The tension between what passes through my mind and what I refuse to let past my lips. Whenever I'm asked what I want, I freeze. Anything that does leave my mouth feels like a lie. I want to make a film, I want to preserve my autonomy. I want love, I want to be alone. I want my worst impressions of others to be proven correct. What could I have said or done that would have kept my ex in my life? Do I regret the way in which that 3-month situationship changed me, marked me? Who would I be if I hadn't found those essays, if I hadn't cracked open Eros the Bittersweet and found the beauty of unsatisfied desire? Do I know myself any better after all of this? Is there an answer to any of these questions at all?
Infants begin to see by noticing the edges of things. How do they know an edge is an edge? By passionately wanting it not to be. The experience of eros as lack alerts a person to the boundaries of himself, of other people, of things in general. It is the edge separating my tongue from the taste for which it longs that teaches me what an edge is. Like Sappho’s adjective glukupikron, the moment of desire is one that defies proper edge, being a compound of opposites forced together at pressure. Pleasure and pain at once register upon the lover, inasmuch as the desirability of the love object derives, in part, from its lack. To whom is it lacking? To the lover. If we follow the trajectory of eros we consistently find it tracing out this same route: it moves out from the lover toward the beloved, then ricochets back to the lover himself and the hole in him, unnoticed before. Who is the real subject of most love poems? Not the beloved. It is that hole.
When I desire you a part of me is gone: my want of you partakes of me. So reasons the lover at the edge of eros. The presence of want awakens in him nostalgia for wholeness. His thoughts turn toward questions of personal identity: he must recover and reincorporate what is gone if he is to be a complete person. (Eros the Bittersweet, Anne Carson, p 52-53)
When I conceptualized this film I was thinking of images loosely connected to tell a story of people getting together and then separating. I was thinking about things separating - legs parting, eyes & lips opening, a cracked door, blinds slightly lifted and the places in which branches and limbs split off. I was thinking of a relationship starting and ending. I guess now I'm concerned with why such a thing would happen. What is my protagonist not saying? How do I make the medium relevant by making this about staining -- permanent and impermanent? It means developing a character to follow, and recognizing that that character's main problem is that they refuse to break past their own armor. They are leaving something unsaid, scared to leave a mark on another person, but being transformed regardless in return. It means, and this I may be a bit uncomfortable with, examining myself and my own relationships and figuring out how to break that cycle of silence and fear.
I've been interested in the erotic for so long. I want to be brave and make art about it. If I reveal myself in the process, so be it.
Comments