Inhabiting a Digital Place - Design Research & Ideas
I am using the project of Tethered Dreams as a testbed for exploring interaction design ideas & narrative elements in realtime 3D space. It's become a space for learning how to build the systems & technology that can shape the kinds of experiences I am hoping to create. In light of this, I have realized that one of the primary research questions for this project is:
How do you preserve the solitude, mystery, atmosphere, and discovery of a game like Myst, while introducing other people whose presence actually contributes to the narrative?
My first instinct is to approach the project as a shared narrative environment, something between an explorable artwork, an immersive theater production, and a social space. It is an interaction model where participants aren't necessarily playing characters or completing objectives; rather, they are inhabiting a place, uncovering its history, and contributing to its ongoing existence.
What should be preserved in translation?
Before thinking about the translation of Myst's design into a multiplayer model, I want to make a few notes as to what makes Myst, and the broader Walking Sim tradition so appealing.
Primarily, I think the power of many of these projects is in the sense that this world exists independently of the player or the audience. Entering one of these worlds feels like entering a place with history, and that things have happened here. The world does not revolve around the player, it lives on its own terms, and you are here to learn some aspect of this world or find some way of engaging with it.
Some elements that build on this in Myst are
- Environmental Storytelling: The world tells its story through its environment: architecture, objects, sounds, landscape, etc..
- Solitude: Being alone in this world encourages attention to the environment.
- Nonlinear exploration: Players can create their own paths in this world, creating a unique and meaningful relationship to the place.
- Mystery: The environment constantly suggests there is more than meets the eye.
With these elements in mind, the central question posed earlier can be dissected into the following:
- How can online interaction be used to build on the environmental storytelling? Can other people's actions leave marks or alter the environment in such a way that it furthers or reinterprets the world's story?
- How can online interaction be used to encourage attention to the environment, rather than distract from it? And can there be some sense of shared solitude in this space?
- Can nonlinear exploration be used to create a unique relationship to not just the space, but the others inhabiting it?
- Can the online component be a part of the mystery? For example, by asking: What are we doing here? Why are we all exploring this space?
Design/Interaction Brainstorming
Presence Indicator / Player Body
A digital world is made accessible by the avatar, the character or body that a "player" animates to interact with the world. A body in a digital world is our interface with it (as is our own real body-in-the-world). Since Tethered Dreams is being designed as a dreamlike, first person point-and-click interaction, the body can take on many forms and not necessarily be human-like.
I have been toying with the idea of the player avatar being a floating eye/orb, whose direct sight upon things can call upon interaction in the world. This type of body effectively mirrors the experience of moving a cursor across a screen and having things respond or react as you hover.
The idea for this kind of player avatar came from a dream I had; it was a lucid dream with a long, winding story I had back in high school. At one point, I found myself floating through the room where I was actually sleeping. I could see my own body lying on the bed while I drifted freely around the space.
Then I noticed orb-like, eye shaped beings entering the room. They watched me silently from a distance. Before long, though, the room was crawling with dozens of them. It was deeply unnerving and disorienting.
In the dream, it felt as though something had gone horribly wrong with my reality, and these watching eyes had arrived from some other place to assess the situation.
This dream inspires the idea behind Tethered Dream's avatar: where you, the player, become one of these watcher eyes. Sent from elsewhere to explore, interpret, and unravel the mystery of this place.
A digital world to be interpreted rather than solved
I want to avoid giving the sense that this is a place that needs to be solved. This is not a world with an endpoint or win condition, but rather intended as a living place that continues before and after any individual player enters it. Some thoughts around this include:
- Narrative Encounters over Quests: Rather than designing quests with win conditions, I want to design around narrative encounters. Designing around narrative encounters, to me, is to think of this digital world as a stage for performance. Here I'm defining narrative encounters as narrative set pieces that can have various "triggers": perhaps a ritual sequence begins when enough players enter a specific room, or an in-world theater scene plays out at a given time of day. A good example of something like this is the concept of abiogenesis in the art game Endless Forest by Tale of Tales. Abiogenesis in The Endless Forest is a live, real-time event where the game's developers (Auriea Harvey and Michael Samyn, known as the Twin Gods) directly manipulate the virtual world to drive live spectacles, emergent events and forest festivals.
- A shared, in-world Archive: I keep coming back to this idea of having the experience be deeply interpretive. I want to take advantage of the fact that the places in Tethered Dreams are constructed out of real-world locations, collaged into new scenes. The 3D scans bring their own histories totally outside of this imagined world, but what if these histories can help create sites for new connection and stories to be drawn and written? My first intuition here is to allow players to leave written records, notes and interpretations physically in the space. This way the digital world accumulates history tangibly as players explore through it–giving the place a real sense of memory. For example, in the game Death Stranding by Hideo Kojima, players traverse large, beautiful, yet lonely landscapes. But as you play, you can build bridges, put down ladders, build structures and leave signs to make other people's journeys across this world easier; and others do the same. Over time, the game's world accumulates this, slowly filling in with people's contributions on this (semi) shared landscape.
- A set of performance instructions rather than game rules: Following the idea of a shared archive above, I am thinking of how this project could revolve around a set of performative instructions. A set of rules provided to the player allowing for some emergent idea-sharing to take place. Though as I'm writing this, perhaps a literal instruction manual is not necessary, game mechanics in a sense already serve as the delineated space of interaction. Concepts like John Cage's chance based operations and instructions for Art as Self-Alteration come to mind here as well
Endless Forest @ Group Hug
Exhibition presented by Onassis ONX
This was a great exhibition with some fantastic talks, and wanted to share the Endless Forest display since I mentioned earlier. Unfortunately I'm having some trouble uploading my own photos (might be the image files), so here's the link from the exhibition's webpage and some of the images on there.
Comments